Maybe J.K. Rowling’s Greatest Battle wasn’t In Harry Potter’s Universe, It’s Versus The Trans Community?

It’s sad seeing bestselling authors like J.K Rowling embroiled in real world battles. I mean she’s had it all as an author. It’s the dream come true that very few writers ever realize. I wrote a few books, some were reviewed pretty well (and no, not shills, not friends and family only), but none sold enough for me to even be a rounding error on J.K Rowling’s most recent royalty statement. Jealous? Sure, what author wouldn’t be? I tried. Maybe I’ll write some more books someday, because I do love fiction writing.

In the meantime, I write here on this blog, though. I’m happy with that. Stay with me, we’re about to slay some dragons …

First, one more thing about me that’s important to point out. I’m probably in the smallest of smallest minority that has never seen any of the Harry Potter movies or read any of the books. Sacrilege! I know, I know, but can still appreciate and marvel at what Rowling has done and the popularity of the series. Maybe I’ll watch one of them someday. If you have recommendations, feel free to hit me up in the comments below.

Those wizard fantasy type books just haven’t ever really been my wheelhouse. I’d rather play Dungeons & Dragons the RPG game than read stories about wizards and magic. That’s not saying I dislike fantasy fiction, no way. It’s just not a genre that I’m super attracted to. I have read and enjoyed some fantasy — a lot.

Understanding that, I don’t have a dog in the J.K Rowling versus the trans community fight. I’m not a fan of Rowling’s work or writing, just a fellow author admirer of her success.

I’ve read plenty of stories about the conflict here and there and it seems like Rowling, despite obviously having great talent with words, has bungled up her messaging on the subject. I’m not sure what’s she’s trying to say or where she’s benefitting from the position she’s taking.

It wasn’t until last summer that Rowling really made her anti-transgender feelings clear, when she released a lengthy screed on her website outlining her “fears” of “trans activism.” For a woman who made billions using the written word, it was a shockingly unreadable piece, full of pseudoscientific nonsense to dress up undeniable bigotry. It was also a pivot sure to shock her audience. The “Harry Potter” series was beloved by readers because it preached messages of tolerance and inclusivity. The evil Voldemort and his followers are characterized as believing in wizarding purity, an unsubtle stand-in for eugenics. And yet, here was the woman credited with turning a whole generation of readers into progressives, suddenly, and loudly, declaring that intolerance was sometimes acceptable. Worse, Rowling hasn’t let it go, circling back every few weeks to remind everyone that she is still dedicated to the transphobic cause.

HBO Max’s ‘Harry Potter’ streaming plans would give J.K. Rowling an undeserved platform

Intolerance is a terrible, unacceptable position to maintain. We should accept other human beings for what they want to be, so long as they do not hurt, infringe or impose upon others — period. I begin stepping off with any group of people when they start trying to tell me what to do, how to think and how to behave. There is some of that being sent J.K Rowling’s direction, but I see the argument for why this is happening.

Rowling has a right to her opinion, however wrong-headed or right she feels it might be, but she shouldn’t be trying to impose her beliefs on others. That’s where she’s most wrong here in my eyes. I could be off here, as I haven’t done deep research on this conflict. Maybe she’s not trying to tell the rest of us how to think involving the trans community, just trying to explain her position better?

One thing is certain, you can’t always get good information following news stories. You have to dig beyond those stories. Full disclosure: I haven’t done that here.

Whatever the case, it seems like it’s a bigger battle than anything I’ve heard about in the Harry Potter series — at least in the last year or so anyway. Or maybe I’ve got this all wrong.

We’ve talked on this site before about implied support for misdeeds — which is tangentially related at best, see: The Mike Tyson Dilemma – does promoting those who’ve done bad in the past imply support for their misdeeds? and Disgraced Sexual Assaulter Roman Polanski Wins Award at ‘French Oscars’. It’s nothing this severe, though. Having a controversial opinion isn’t the same as committing a violent or disgusting criminal act. Still, the point is Harry Potter is safe as a creative work no matter what J.K Rowling says or does. Might not be as popular or revered, but the work itself should stand on its own merits.

Oh, and I haven’t seen Fantastic Beasts either.

If I’ve got this wrong, please feel free to correct my thoughts on this in the comments area. Please keep it civil, as always, and if I follow up your comment with a comment, let’s have a reasonable discussion. Can we do that? We keep a respectful house here and don’t need any blood on the walls — except when speaking about horror 🙂

4 thoughts on “Maybe J.K. Rowling’s Greatest Battle wasn’t In Harry Potter’s Universe, It’s Versus The Trans Community?

  1. A successful author no doubt, writing children’s fantasy books and making a “screw you” fortune. She is no Hemingway or Steinbeck, but she found a hole in the fence and used it well. She is like most wealthy celebrities that we hear from daily. They view themselves as superior because they have money, thus they have the right to chastise the rest for not thinking like they do. Hollywood is full of them, and now it appears the literary world is catching up. Rowling can say what she wishes on her website, and her readers have the right to not read her books or see her movies if they feel different. I don’t believe she is a hateful person, just radically opinionated. She made her fortune early on, so she feels that she can take a stand on anything she see’s fit. I don’t think the downside bothers her. I’m not a fan, nor have I read more than a few chapters of her first book and seen only one movie. Good article.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Here’s a curious anecdote that shows just how far Rowling has reached with this series. “Screw you money” is a great way to put it! lol

      Watching this mini-series on fallen NFL tightend and convicted murderer Aaron Hernandez this past weekend.. He’s in prison and asks his wife to send him books. Which ones? “Harry Potters”

      Hernandez committed suicide in 2017 shortly after news came out about him being bisexual and not long after he was found not guilty of two additional murders.

      Like

  2. I’m sad she’s doubled-down on this as much as she has. I understand some of where she’s coming from. It does concern me when I suddenly see around me so many young people convinced they are trans. I am concerned for them and that they are being counseled wisely. Could it just be a phase? I don’t know, I’ve never been trans or had any different feelings like that. I was a tom-boy growing up and occasionally had the teasing that came along with it, including about what some perceived as me being “a lesbo.” I think people need to be free to explore what they are, but I hope the openness they experience isn’t also a push in a certain direction.

    That said, she is certainly entitled to her position and to explain it. She’s not entitled to force others to live by it. I’ve been saying that for years to many conservatives and it’s the same for everyone – you can’t legislate a certain brand of “morality”. If she’s giving her money to people who are determined to put trans people bac in the closet, that’s a bad decision and I wouldn’t blame people who no longer wish to support anything she’s connected with because of that.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s